• What We Do
  • Our Team
  • Our Associates
  • Portfolio
  • Blog
  • Contact Us
  • Gender Digital Divide Course
  • About
Menu

Panoply Digital

Sustainable development through appropriate technology
  • What We Do
  • Our Team
  • Our Associates
  • Portfolio
  • Blog
  • Contact Us
  • Gender Digital Divide Course
  • About

Blog

  • November 2018 1
  • October 2018 1
  • August 2018 2
  • June 2018 2
  • May 2018 1
  • April 2018 3
  • March 2018 3
  • February 2018 3
  • January 2018 2
  • December 2017 4
  • November 2017 2
  • October 2017 3
  • September 2017 7
  • August 2017 3
  • July 2017 5
  • June 2017 4
  • May 2017 3
  • April 2017 4
  • March 2017 5
  • February 2017 4
  • January 2017 3
  • December 2016 2
  • November 2016 3
  • October 2016 2
  • September 2016 5
  • August 2016 4
  • July 2016 4
  • June 2016 4
  • May 2016 5
  • April 2016 4
  • March 2016 3
  • February 2016 4
  • January 2016 4
  • December 2015 2
  • November 2015 4
  • October 2015 4
  • September 2015 4
  • August 2015 4
  • July 2015 4
  • June 2015 5
  • May 2015 4
  • April 2015 4
  • March 2015 5
  • February 2015 2
  • January 2015 1
  • November 2014 1
By Michael Gallagher

Surveillance and silence: the rise of curbs on communication

June 17, 2017

Surveillance and the lack of security are two of the larger issues in the world of ICT4D precisely because they attack the very trust and openness that predicates much of what makes the internet a potentially valuable tool for development. Imagine for a moment how much of what we do online is predicated on trust. From online banking or shopping, to mobile or eHealth initiatives, to basic education and communication. All of it is predicated to some degree on the belief that I am safe, I am secure, and I am being left alone. Surveillance and the lack of security attack all of these.

 And the wedge being used to lever this surveillance onto either unwilling or apathetic audiences is safety. Threats from terrorism, against civil society being torn asunder in public strife, to labor protests, and the instability caused by natural or manmade disasters. Safety, safety, safety. Until we find a means of balancing safety and openness with some transparency, trust and openness will continue to erode. Granted this isn’t a particularly development phenomena as other nations are just as likely to surveil their citizens as developing ones. But often in development contexts this surveillance takes a particularly destructive turn as it erodes trust not only in ICT but in civil society itself: the public institutions burgeoning from often fragile representative governments.

In Kenya, the government monitors private chats without alluding to how (“Nkaissery did not explain how the state will tap into private conversations, though he said security agencies have been supplied with devices that can do so, according to published reports”), suggesting either a bluff (doubtful) or technological solutions either domestic of foreign (likely).  

“Despite assurances to the contrary just two months ago, Interior CS Joseph Nkaissery said this week that the government has purchased equipment it will use to monitor private communications and ensure that citizens do not violate hate-speech laws, according to published reports. “Private chats” will be “monitored to the letter and our officers will come for you,” Nkaissery was quoted as saying by Nairobi media outlets...This announcement relates to Kenyans' anger earlier this year over fears the Communications Authority was spying on them. The CA insisted, though, that its device management system would only detect counterfeit devices in the country and stop SIM-box technology, which is illegal in Kenya. The Consumers Federation of Kenya (COFEK) announced its opposition to the plan, calling it an attempt to monitor citizens’ calls and text messages with the help of a system set to be imposed on mobile network operators.”

Something to monitor there as this develops but good on COFEK for pushing back and hopefully more organisations will do as well.  

In Ethiopia, the government goes so far as to shut down the mobile internet altogether. Ethiopia has been censoring the internet for more than a decade, and social media sites like Facebook and Twitter have been blocked since unrest last year (2016). Journalist repression and free speech curtailment are major issues as “just last month, an Ethiopian court sentenced opposition politician Yonatan Tesfaye to six and a half years in prison for allegedly criticising the government through his Facebook posts.”

“The nationwide mobile internet blackout started on Tuesday. Ethiopia's internet service is entirely in the hands of Ethio Telecom, the state-owned telecom provider. It's the third time within a year that Ethio Telecom has taken such action. According to Ethiopian blogger Danel Birhane, the blackout has left very few companies and organizations online - only the ones that have alternative means of connectivity such as satellite communication.“

 In Turkey as part of the continuing purge by President/Autocrat Erdoğan, twenty teachers were detained in a supposed investigation into the Gulen Movement, which the government accuses of spearheading the July 15, 2016 coup attempt. The mobile connection here is that they were accused of using the ByLock mobile application, which prosecutors claim is the preferred app for the Gulen Movement. Thousand has so far been jailed for using the application. The crackdown has detained more than 120,000 people including thousands of teachers and academics since last summer. In case you want to learn more about ByLock, click here but do be careful if you are in Turkey. Stay safe my Turkish friends.  

There are many more of these examples. So let’s give security and surveillance the attention it deserves. It has the potential to undermine much of what we do, or any hope we have of doing it. Use secure apps like Signal and Telegram. Instead of Slack, consider Semaphor. Use encrypted email add-ons like Virtru. Do sweeps or audits of locally stored data. Teach your communities to do the same, to protect themselves. None of this needs to be inevitable. Push back.

← Social media for advocacy: changing perceptions, one workshop at a time(Open) Data ICT4D Meetup Presentations →

Recent Posts

Featured
SDGs accelerating mobility and massification in (higher) education
Nov 30, 2018
SDGs accelerating mobility and massification in (higher) education
Nov 30, 2018

A few caveats at the onset here. This reads a bit more like an academic piece which it largely is. It is drawn from something larger I wrote a bit ago for another paper. It might also read like an attack on the SDGs, which is not my point. The point here is that the SDGs have generated some incredible results and I sincerely support them, but we must be mindful of what is being mobilised in our pursuit of them. My focus is education and I suggest that the provisions of the SDGs related specifically to that field suggest particular scaled interventions (or at least make those approaches particularly attractive). Scale exacts pressure on particular types of education.

Read More →
Nov 30, 2018
Digital education, Syrian displaced academics, and mushrooms: report from a recent workshop in Turkey
Oct 5, 2018
Digital education, Syrian displaced academics, and mushrooms: report from a recent workshop in Turkey
Oct 5, 2018

As part of my association with the Centre for Research in Digital Education at the University of Edinburgh (a version of this post appears there as well), I recently traveled with colleagues to deliver a three day workshop on digital education for Syrian academics who have been displaced by the conflict. The University has worked for a long time with the Council for At-Risk Academics (CARA), a great organisation providing urgently-needed help to academics in immediate danger, those forced into exile, and many who choose to work on in their home countries despite serious risks.

Read More →
Oct 5, 2018
Five things to consider for improving our ICT4D interventions
Aug 29, 2018
Five things to consider for improving our ICT4D interventions
Aug 29, 2018

We seem to have endless ideas on how to use Information and Communication Technologies for Development (ICT4D). From job creation to women’s empowerment to civic participation, a number of ICT4D interventions have been developed and implemented over the years. Common question asked in my work is “what type of technology that might have biggest impact in our society in the coming years?”. As we have learned, ICTs in itself aren’t sufficient. While factors contributing to the success of ICT4D have become apparent, and many have written about them, I feel there's still a need to highlight some of them.

Read More →
Aug 29, 2018
Aug 20, 2018
How Relevant was Bridge International Academies' EdTech Intervention in Liberia?
Aug 20, 2018

We have been some of the most vocal critics of Bridge International Academies (BIA), largely because most investigations and evaluations of their edtech impact to improve schooling in sub-Saharan Africa have been less than spectacular (many would say the impact is non-existent). So imagine our surprise to see Wayan Vota's latest ICTworks™ post highlighting the successes of BIA in Liberia.

Read More →
Aug 20, 2018
Stories of innovation and gender imbalance: in conversation with Tanya Accone
Jun 8, 2018
Stories of innovation and gender imbalance: in conversation with Tanya Accone
Jun 8, 2018

We need to make women in innovation more visible, and correct the gender imbalance in the stories we tell. We need to tell more stories about the women working at the top of humanitarian innovation, and so today I sat down with Tanya Accone, Senior Advisor at UNICEF Innovation, to tell the story of a woman working at the top of a very visible humanitarian innovation team for a very visible humanitarian agency.

Read More →
Jun 8, 2018
Surfacing local practice, placelessness, and digital education
Jun 4, 2018
Surfacing local practice, placelessness, and digital education
Jun 4, 2018

We do a lot of work on open learning as well and it was clear there was tension between these open educational platforms (like Coursera, edX, etc.) and their use in local contexts, particularly in emerging economies. There is tension there. Open educational technologies are too often framed as a transparent instrument for educational export, keeping (specifically Western or Global North) curricula, pedagogy, and educational values intact whilst they are broadcast to a global population in deficit.

Read More →
Jun 4, 2018
May 22, 2018
Got bots? A beginners guide to Facebook (chat)bots 4 good
May 22, 2018

I remember when I first started hearing the buzz about bots. My first thought? 'Here we go again...' - a reaction to the endless cycles of hype followed by business-as-usual that typifies the digital sector. However, over the past few months I've had the opportunity to design a few 'bots 4 good', and I'd like to share what I've learned: how they work, what they could be useful for, and where to start if you'd like to get one. I believe that done well, they could be really useful add-ons to your digital strategy as they provide a rich 'in-between' space for mobile users who aren't fully digitally literate.

Read More →
May 22, 2018
How can we ensure that the citizens, government and civil society work together?
Apr 25, 2018
How can we ensure that the citizens, government and civil society work together?
Apr 25, 2018

Last week, I was at TICTeC 2018 where researchers, activists and practitioners discussed the impact of civic technology, or civic tech. This blogpost summarises the discussion of Two heads are better than one: working with governments.

Read More →
Apr 25, 2018
Apr 15, 2018
The Nexus of ICT4D and Environmental Justice: A US Perspective
Apr 15, 2018

Well, as a Black American woman from a low-income background, I constantly say that "development" not only takes place in Africa, Asia, and any other place typically associated with the Global South. There are several places even in the world's "richest" country that reflect not only deprivation but what happens when environmental justice is not served. In light of this and in honor of Earth Day on Monday April 22, in this post I will focus on the nexus of ICT4D and environmental justice in the US.

Read More →
Apr 15, 2018
AI in ICT4D: Accumulated Advantage, Data Driven Bias and Invisibility, and Ethical Care
Apr 10, 2018
AI in ICT4D: Accumulated Advantage, Data Driven Bias and Invisibility, and Ethical Care
Apr 10, 2018

With artificial intelligence (and perhaps with all things technological), we as humans seem to run the gamut between dystopian visions of complete AI takeover and dysfunction (think HAL) and utopian daydreams of gracious ubiquity where personal assistants attend to the less pleasant aspects of daily life (think every edtech advertisement ever, and an increasing portion of Amazon’s advertising budget it would seem). AI is pervasive, regardless of how you critique it.

Read More →
Apr 10, 2018

© 2018 Panoply Digital Ltd. Incorporated at Companies House as Company Number 938241.