• What We Do
  • Our Team
  • Our Associates
  • Portfolio
  • Blog
  • Contact Us
  • Gender Digital Divide Course
Menu

Panoply Digital

Sustainable development through appropriate technology
  • What We Do
  • Our Team
  • Our Associates
  • Portfolio
  • Blog
  • Contact Us
  • Gender Digital Divide Course
 

Blog

  • April 2018 3
  • March 2018 3
  • February 2018 3
  • January 2018 2
  • December 2017 4
  • November 2017 2
  • October 2017 3
  • September 2017 7
  • August 2017 3
  • July 2017 5
  • June 2017 4
  • May 2017 3
  • April 2017 4
  • March 2017 5
  • February 2017 4
  • January 2017 3
  • December 2016 2
  • November 2016 3
  • October 2016 2
  • September 2016 5
  • August 2016 4
  • July 2016 4
  • June 2016 4
  • May 2016 5
  • April 2016 4
  • March 2016 3
  • February 2016 4
  • January 2016 4
  • December 2015 2
  • November 2015 4
  • October 2015 4
  • September 2015 4
  • August 2015 4
  • July 2015 4
  • June 2015 5
  • May 2015 4
  • April 2015 4
  • March 2015 5
  • February 2015 2
  • January 2015 1
  • November 2014 1
MobileMoney1.jpg
By Alexandra Tyers

Mobile money: the solution to the gender digital divide?

September 20, 2015

One thing we do like to talk about in the ICT4D community is how everyone is working in silos, particularly when it comes to mobile services for women: “no one talks to anyone else, we’re all doing the same thing in the same country, we need to work together more”. I do think, actually, this is very true: one example I like to cite are two commercial mobile maternal health services aimed at women in Northern Nigeria; both delivered through IVR and SMS, both using similar content and both launched at the same time to the same audience but with different mobile operators and partners. While some may argue there’s nothing wrong with a little healthy market competition, I do think there’s something here we need to look at if we have the same aims of improving socio-economic outcomes for women, but end up merely duplicating efforts. With this in mind, the ICT4D community also likes to talk about scale and meaningful impact (my colleague Lauren Dawes’ excellent recent blog post talks about this in more detail) and we are often looking for the best way to scale and replicate mobile services in order to reach more women and to reduce the gender digital divide. Much has been made recently of the role of mobile money in this: because there’s evidence that mobile money works across different contexts, doesn’t need to be customized and sits on a reusable platform (unlike services on other verticals that tend to use more bespoke platforms that have to be customized to each context), it may be that investing in mobile money services are the most logical way to drive increase in uptake and meaningful use of mobile for women, rather than other services such as health, education or agriculture. To paraphrase comments by a gender and mobile expert who I spoke to recently:

“Empowerment for women in developing countries means making money. We can bring women online / give them access to mobiles, but for what end? The end seems to be financial inclusion. Women equate finances to empowerment, and so the only way to get women to use mobile is to give them a real reason or incentive for using mobile – not for maternal health messages, or for weather forecasts, but for access to money; and that means mobile money.”

 If you look at M-Pesa, that’s often cited as best practice for real, scalable success in mobile money, particularly for women. GSMA Connected Women recently credited it as being responsible for helping to reduce the gender digital divide in Kenya to just 7%, explaining that “M-Pesa was a catalyst to women owning phones…it allows cheap and efficient money transfers, often from sons or husbands working away from home to their mothers or wives. The cost savings of cutting out middlemen, transport costs and fees, as well as the safety and security of M-Pesa, are beneficial enough to justify the costs of mobile phone ownership.”

 However, at the same time, skeptics argue that there is no empirical evidence to support this claim – that data is based on qualitative interviews with stakeholders, rather than robust quantitative data looking at trends in female mobile phone ownership and mobile money use in Kenya. Indeed, if you look at Bangladesh, which has long been the poster child for financial inclusion for women due to microfinance pioneered by Grameen Bank and BRAC, digital financial services experts argue that the gender digital gap is actually reversing current practices around financial inclusion: women were leaders in microfinances, but because there are increasing numbers of digital payments and Bangladeshi women are more digitally excluded than men, they are becoming increasingly financially excluded. It’s more logical that a gender gap in access will be followed by a gender gap in mobile money access and use – not necessarily the other way round.

So is mobile money the answer to reducing the gender gap in mobile access and use? I’m not sure. I think no – quite apart from the relatively weak evidence base, how do you conclusively prioritize one vertical as being more important to invest in than others? How do you conclusively say that financial services are more important than health or education services - I’ve written before about the fundamental importance of education in addressing social norms and gender inequality. Mobile for development is still a new field – we need to test lots of different ideas out, build the evidence base and learn from others before we can conclusively say mobile money is the answer. It might be – but I don’t think we’re there yet.

 

In News Tags Bangladesh, Development, gender, gender digital divide, gender equality, ICT4D, Kenya, M-Pesa, m4d, MFS, mobile, mobile money, scale, technology, women
← Mobile learning for Syrian refugees: marshaling resources and resilienceNew Online Tool for Transparent and Accountable Government in Africa: A Review →

Recent Posts

Featured
How can we ensure that the citizens, government and civil society work together?
Apr 25, 2018
How can we ensure that the citizens, government and civil society work together?
Apr 25, 2018

Last week, I was at TICTeC 2018 where researchers, activists and practitioners discussed the impact of civic technology, or civic tech. This blogpost summarises the discussion of Two heads are better than one: working with governments.

Read More →
Apr 25, 2018
Apr 15, 2018
The Nexus of ICT4D and Environmental Justice: A US Perspective
Apr 15, 2018

Well, as a Black American woman from a low-income background, I constantly say that "development" not only takes place in Africa, Asia, and any other place typically associated with the Global South. There are several places even in the world's "richest" country that reflect not only deprivation but what happens when environmental justice is not served. In light of this and in honor of Earth Day on Monday April 22, in this post I will focus on the nexus of ICT4D and environmental justice in the US.

Read More →
Apr 15, 2018
AI in ICT4D: Accumulated Advantage, Data Driven Bias and Invisibility, and Ethical Care
Apr 10, 2018
AI in ICT4D: Accumulated Advantage, Data Driven Bias and Invisibility, and Ethical Care
Apr 10, 2018

With artificial intelligence (and perhaps with all things technological), we as humans seem to run the gamut between dystopian visions of complete AI takeover and dysfunction (think HAL) and utopian daydreams of gracious ubiquity where personal assistants attend to the less pleasant aspects of daily life (think every edtech advertisement ever, and an increasing portion of Amazon’s advertising budget it would seem). AI is pervasive, regardless of how you critique it.

Read More →
Apr 10, 2018
whatsapp vs. gender based violence: notes on a pilot
Mar 21, 2018
whatsapp vs. gender based violence: notes on a pilot
Mar 21, 2018

This is part three in a series of blogs tracing each step of an iterative approach to digital programme design. As part of a UNFPA-funded project run by OneWorld to explore strategies to tackle Gender Based Violence (G.B.V.) using ICTs, we decided a sensible entry-point was to address the lack of information about laws and services in rural Benin, working with stakeholders to co-create messages for dissemination via WhatsApp and SMS. This blog details the process and results of rapid-testing this model.

Read More →
Mar 21, 2018
Getting ICT Into the hands of more women
Mar 8, 2018
Getting ICT Into the hands of more women
Mar 8, 2018

March 8 is International Women’s Day! To celebrate, we look at a course on women and ICT inclusion developed by USAID Digital Inclusion, mSTAR, and Panoply Digital.

Read More →
Mar 8, 2018
Mar 2, 2018
Wakanda forever: a fintech tribute
Mar 2, 2018

By the time you are reading this blog post, you most probably have already gone to the movies to watch Black Panther. If not, do yourself a favour: stop reading and go watch it NOW.

Yet, regardless of whether you watched it or not, I hope you have come across the bountiful articles, tweets and social media posts that describe what makes it so revolutionary: it is the first Hollywood blockbuster movie to have an African-American director, starring a predominantly black cast, with the first black super hero. Above all, it is a celebration of blackness and a movie that finally offers black people the representation they deserve: that of powerful, smart, creative and beautiful people.

Read More →
Mar 2, 2018
Indonesia needs net neutrality protections, urgently
Feb 22, 2018
Indonesia needs net neutrality protections, urgently
Feb 22, 2018

Net neutrality rules may address many issues of the internet users in Indonesia. Indonesia, however, doesn’t have such rules. The time is ripe for the country to adopt them.

Read More →
Feb 22, 2018
Feb 11, 2018
A Digital Angle to Oxfam's #MeToo Moment?
Feb 11, 2018

Last week I think many of us who work in international development were quite shocked and disappointed to learn of the scandal with Oxfam employees who paid (?) prostitutes for sex, in housing provided by Oxfam no less. Before we had time to say that this was an isolated incident, it emerged that possibly the same thing had happened in Chad with a man implicated in the Haiti scandal, Roland van Hauwermeiren. These incidents are in no way solely a problem of Oxfam, or of international development more broadly, but rather form a part of the overarching and global challenges around men who commit violence against women and girls with relatively little impunity. I believe this Oxfam story may be the start of the #MeToo movement shining its light on injustices in international development. In this blog post, I'll explain why mobile should urgently be considered as a safeguard to help prevent further abuses of this nature.

Read More →
Feb 11, 2018
Bangladesh’s first app for women by women: in conversation with Ivy Russell, CEO of Maya Apa
Feb 2, 2018
Bangladesh’s first app for women by women: in conversation with Ivy Russell, CEO of Maya Apa
Feb 2, 2018

Over the Christmas and New Year period, I was back in Dhaka - catching up with friends and family, but also spending time with movers and shakers in the Bangladesh ICT4D space. I spent a day with Drinkwell visiting their mobile-enabled ‘water ATMs’ in low-income communities in Dhaka, and I also spent some time with Ivy Russell and the Maya Apa team.

Read More →
Feb 2, 2018
Mobile Mentoring in Teacher Training: ideas, projects, and further development
Jan 26, 2018
Mobile Mentoring in Teacher Training: ideas, projects, and further development
Jan 26, 2018

I have been working a bit recently with colleagues in Finland, Nigeria, and Nepal on developing a more robust teacher training curriculum for delivery in low resource environments primarily through mobile. There is activity in this space so this isn't a novel idea, but I'd rather be focused on impact over originality. At least that is what I tell myself. I wrote a bit about it a few years ago.

Read More →
Jan 26, 2018

© 2018 Panoply Digital Ltd. Incorporated at Companies House as Company Number 938241.